Board of Governors

Date: 
Thursday, November 20, 2008 - 12:00am
Location: 
Agenda: 
1. Welcome to New Members
Mr. Slim Babay, LUSU Graduate Representative
Ms. Vonnie Cheng, Alumni Association Representative
Dr. Gillian Siddall, Senate Representative
Dr. Ethel Gardner, Senate Representative
Mr. Ewan Downie, Elected
Mr. Anthony LeBlanc, Elected
Ms. Darlene Palmer, Elected
Ms. Frances Picherack, Elected
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Declaration of Conflict of Interest
4. Chair's Report
5. Approval of Minutes of the Board of Governors' Meeting of October 17, 2008
6. Business Arising from the Minutes (not on the Agenda elsewhere)
** University Information Session - Dr. Bill Montelpare - Science of Injury in Sport: The Ice Hockey Perspective**
7. President's Report
8. Standing Committee Reports
8.1 Audit & Risk Management Committee (Mr. J. Dennison, Chair)
Moved that the Board of Governors approve the Audit & Risk Management Committee 2008/09 Action Plan as presented.
8.2 Finance & Investment Committee (Ms. A. Dumyn, Chair)
Moved that the Board of Governors approve the Finance & Investment Committee 2008/09 Action Plan as presented.
8.3 Compensation Committee (Mr. D. Campbell, Chair)
Moved that the Board of Governors approve the Action Plan for 2008/09 as presented by the Compensation Committee.
8.4 Governance Committee (Mr. D. Campbell, Chair)
8.4.1 2008/09 Action Plan
Moved that the Board of Governors approve the Action Plan for 2008/09 as presented by the Governance Committee.
8.4.2 Review of 2009 Retreat Agenda
8.4.3 Proposed By-Laws Amendments - Finance & Investment Committee
Moved that the proposed By-Law amendment to the Finance & Investment Committee be approved by the Board of Governors.
8.5 Nominating Committee (Mr. D. Campbell, Chair).
8.5.1 2008/09 Action Plan
Moved that the Board of Governors approve the Action Plan for 2008/09 as presented by the Nominating Committee.
8.5.2 Request for Nominations for Award of Lakehead University Fellow
8.5.3 Nomination of Board Members to the President Search Committee
Moved that the following Board members be appointed to the Presidential Search Committee: (5 Board members).
Moved that ________, Vice-President (_____) be appointed to the Presidential Search Committee.
8.5.4 Nomination to the Finance & Investment Committee
Moved that ________ be appointed to the Finance & Investment Committee to replace Mr. James Dennison.
8.5.5 Approval of Voting Non-Governors to the University Advancement Committee
Moved that Mr. Cam Clarke, Mr. Bill Covello, and Mr. Paul Weber be appointed to the University Advancement Committee as voting non-Governor members.
8.6 NOSM Committee (Mr. G. Labine)
Moved that the Board of Governors approve the Action Plan for 2008/09 as presented by the NOSM Committee.
8.7 Operations Committee (Mr. Colin Bruce Chair)
Moved that the Board of Governors approve the Action Plan for 2008/09 as presented by the Operations Committee.
8.8 Senate Liaison Committee (Dr. J. Leggatt, Chair)
Moved that the Board of Governors approve the Action Plan for 2008/09 as presented by the Senate Liaison Committee.
8.9 Student Liaison Committee (Mr. P. Holt-Hindle, Chair)
8.10 University Advancement Committee (Mr. A. Crooks, Chair)
Moved that the Board of Governors approve the Action Plan for 2008/09 as presented by the University Advancement Committee.
9. Report of the Alumni Association (Ms. V. Cheng, Alumni Association Representative)
Moved that the Report of the Alumni Association be accepted.
10. Ratification of Adjunct Professors (Dr. F. Gilbert)
Moved that Mr. Kevin Cleghorn be ratified as an Adjunct Professor in the Department of Political Science for the term July 1, 2008 to June 30, 2012.
Moved that Dr. Michael Campbell be ratified as an Adjunct Professor in the Department of Chemistry for the term July 1, 2008 to June 30, 2012.
Moved that Dr. Monica Vermani be ratified as an Adjunct Professor in the Department of Psychology for the term July 1, 2008 to June 30, 2012.
Moved that Dr. Diane Walker be ratified as an Adjunct Professor in the School of Social Work for the term July 1, 2008 to June 30, 2012.
Moved that Dr. Laura Curiel be ratified as an Adjunct Professor in the Department of Electrical Engineering for the term July 1, 2008 to June 30, 2012.
Moved that Dr. Samuel Pichardo be ratified as an Adjunct Professor in the Department of Electrical Engineering for the term July 1, 2008 to June 30, 2012.
Items for Information
11. Report of the Lakehead University Student Union (Mr. R. Longtin)
12. Report from the Thunder Bay Regional Health Sciences Centre Hospital Board (Mr. G. Labine)
13. Report of the Northern Ontario School of Medicine
14. Report of the Board of Governors' Representative to Senate (Mr. K. Dahl)
15. Re-appointment of Chair of Aboriginal Education in the Faculty of Education (Dr. F. Gilbert)
16. In Camera Meeting
Minutes: 
1.Welcome to New Members
Mr. Cleghorn welcomed new members - Mr. Slim Babay, Ms. Vonnie Cheng, Mr. Ewan Downie, Dr. Ethel Gardner, Mr. Anthony LeBlanc, Ms. Darlene Palmer, Ms. Frances Picherack, Dr. Gillian Siddall.
2.Approval of Agenda
Moved by Mr. Campbell, seconded by Mr. Heroux that the Agenda be approved as circulated.
Carried unanimously.
3.Declaration of Conflict of Interest
Mssrs. Cleghorn and Labine declared a conflict with item 10.
4.Chair's Report
Mr. Cleghorn announced that Mr. Harvey Cardwell's Lieutenant Governor-in-Council term expires on December 1, 2008, adding that Mr. Cardwell has been a Board member for 9 years. He thanked Mr. Cardwell for his dedication and support to Lakehead University and the Board of Governors.
5. Approval of Minutes of the Board of Governors' Meeting of October 17, 2008
The Minutes were circulated with the Agenda.
Moved by Mr. Bruce, seconded by Mr. Cardwell that the Minutes of the Board of Governors' Meeting of October 17, 2008 be approved as circulated.
Mr. Heroux noted a correction on page 8 - "May 2008" should read "April 2008".
Carried with 1 correction.
6. Business Arising from the Minutes (not on the Agenda elsewhere)
There was no business arising from the Minutes.
[Mssrs. Downie and McKinnon joined the meeting.]
Dr. Leggatt, Chair of the Senate Liaison Committee, introduced Dr. Bill Montepare, School of Kinesiology. Dr. Montelpare delivered a presentation entitled "Science of Injury in Sport - The Ice Hockey Perspective".

7.President's Report
Dr. Gilbert reviewed his Report which had been distributed at the beginning of the meeting.
8.Standing Committees Reports
8.1 Audit & Risk Management Committee
Mr. Dennison reviewed the Report and Action Plan which had been circulated at the beginning of the meeting.
Moved by Mr. Dennison, seconded by Mr. Pile that the Board of Governors approve the Audit & Risk Management Committee 2008/09 Action Plan as presented.
Carried unanimously.
Moved by Mr. Dennison, seconded by Ms. Cheng that the Report of the Audit & Risk Management Committee be accepted.
Carried unanimously.
8.2 Finance & Investment Committee
Ms. Dumyn drew members' attention to the Committee's Report which had been circulated at the beginning of the meeting.
Moved by Ms. Dumyn, seconded by Mr. Dennison that the Board of Governors approve the revised Trust and Endowment Management Policy as circulated.
Ms. Dumyn reported that the spending or "pay-out" rate for each endowment was revised to no greater than two (2) percent from no greater than five (5) percent, noting that the change in rate reflects the current conditions in the investment market.
Carried unanimously.
Moved by Ms. Dumyn, seconded by Ms. Phipps that the Board of Governors approve the Finance & Investment Committee 2008/09 Action Plan as presented.
Carried unanimously.
Moved by Ms. Dumyn, seconded by Dr. Leggatt that the Report of the Finance & Investment Committee be accepted.
Carried unanimously.
8.3Compensation Committee
Mr. Campbell advised members that the Action Plan had been circulated with the Agenda.
Moved by Mr. Campbell, seconded by Mr. Kurt Dahl that the Board of Governors approve the Action Plan for 2008/09 as presented by the Compensation Committee.
Carried unanimously.
8.4Governance Committee
Mr. Campbell drew members' attention to the Governance documents which had been circulated with the Agenda.
8.4.1 2008/09 Action Plan
Moved by Mr. Campbell, seconded by Mr. McKinnon that the Board of Governors approve the Action Plan for 2008/09 as presented by the Governance Committee.
Carried unanimously.
8.4.2 Review of 2009 Retreat Agenda
Mr. Campbell reported that the 2009 Retreat Agenda had been circulated with the Agenda. He noted that the Retreat would consist of Lakehead's future financial challenges, the seven-year Strategic Advancement Plan, as well as the 2010-2013 Strategic Plan. Ms Dumyn commented on the success of the facilitator last year, adding that she would like the Governance Committee to consider using a facilitator again this year. Mr. Campbell informed members that the Governance Committee would be meeting shortly and would discuss the use of a facilitator.
Moved by Mr. Campbell, seconded by Mr. Pile that the Board of Governors approve the 2009 Retreat Agenda.
Carried unanimously.
8.4.3 Proposed By-Law Amendments - Finance & Investment Committee
Moved by Mr. Campbell, seconded by Ms. Dumyn that the proposed By-Law amendment to the Finance & Investment Committee be approved by the Board of Governors.
Carried unanimously.
Moved by Mr. Campbell, seconded by Mr. Downie that the verbal Report of the Governance Committee be accepted.
Carried unanimously.
8.5 Nominating Committee
8.5.1 2008/09 Action Plan
Moved by Mr. Campbell, seconded by Ms. Palmer that the Board of Governors approve the Action Plan for 2008/09 as presented by the Nominating Committee.
Carried unanimously.
8.5.2 Request for Nominations for Award of Lakehead University Fellow
Moved by Mr. Campbell, seconded by Mr. Waite the Board of Governors approve the revised Fellow of the University Award Criteria.
Carried unanimously.
8.5.3 Nomination of Board Members to the President Search Committee
Moved by Mr. Campbell, seconded by Ms. Dumyn that the following Board members be appointed to the Presidential Search Committee: Mr. Colin Bruce, Ms. Vonnie Cheng, Mr. Kurt Dahl, Mr. Gil Labine, and Ms. Maria Phipps.
Mr. Boulet informed Mr. Cleghorn that he would like his name to stand for nomination to the Presidential Search Committee. Mr. Babay and Mr. Holt-Hindle nominated Mr. Alex Boulet. Mr. Cleghorn called for further nominations. There were none. The Chair noted that there were six nominations for 5 positions. The Board agreed that a ballot would be developed and Mssrs. Covello and Weber would act as scrutineers. It was also agreed that business would continue and the ballot outcome would take place later in the Agenda.
Moved by Mr. Campbell, seconded by Mr. LeBlanc that Mr. Michael Pawlowski, Vice-President (Administration & Finance) be appointed to the Presidential Search Committee.
Carried unanimously.
8.5.4 Nomination to the Finance & Investment Committee
Moved by Mr. Campbell, seconded by Ms. Dumyn that Mr. Anthony LeBlanc be appointed to the Finance & Investment Committee to replace Mr. James Dennison.
Carried unanimously.
8.5.5 Approval of Voting Non-Governors to the University Advancement Committee
Moved by Mr. Campbell, seconded by Mr. McKinnon that Mr. Cam Clark, Mr. Bill Covello, and Mr. Paul Weber be appointed to the University Advancement Committee as voting non-Governor members.
Carried unanimously.
8.6 NOSM Committee
Mr. Labine reported that the 2008/09 Action Plan had been circulated at the beginning of the meeting.
Moved by Mr. Labine, seconded by Mr. Cardwell that the Board of Governors approve the Action Plan for 2008/09 as presented by the NOSM Committee.
Carried unanimously.
8.7 Operations Committee
Mr. Bruce, Chair of the Operations Committee, reviewed the Committee's Annual Report which had been circulated with the Agenda.
Moved by Mr. Bruce, seconded by Mr. Waite that the Board of Governors approve the Action Plan for 2008/09 as presented by the Operations Committee.
Carried unanimously.
8.8 Senate Liaison Committee
Dr. Leggatt reviewed the 2008/09 Action Plan which had been circulated with the Agenda.
Moved by Dr. Leggatt, seconded by Mr. McKinnon that the Board of Governors approve the Action Plan for 2008/09 as presented by the Senate Liaison Committee.
Carried unanimously.
8.9 Student Liaison Committee
Mr. Holt-Hindle, Chair of the Student Liaison Committee, informed Governors that the Committee has not met, adding that a meeting has been scheduled for mid December.
8.10 University Advancement Committee
Mr. Crooks advised members that the Action Plan which had been circulated with the Agenda was prepared by the Vice-President (University Advancement) and the Chair, adding that the Committee will be meeting November 21, 2008 to review the Plan.
Moved by Mr. Crooks, seconded by Ms. Phipps that the Board of Governors approve the Action Plan for 2008/09 as presented by the Chair of the University Advancement Committee.
Carried unanimously.
Mr. Crooks thanked the Nominating Committee for approving the addition of Mr. Paul Weber, Chair, Orillia Campus Campaign, Mr. Bill Covello, Chair, PACI/Law School Campaign, and Mr. Cam Clark as voting members of the University Advancement Committee. Mr. Crooks advised members that the Committee would be meeting Friday morning and at that time Mr. John Singer, Vice-President (University Advancement), would be presenting a seven-year strategic plan which contains plans for both building the advancement program to maturity, and addressing the critical financial challenges with which the University is presently faced. In addition, the seven-year plan will lead up to the University's 50th Anniversary and will subsequently recommend a large fundraising campaign in conjunction with that celebration. He concluded by reminding Governors that the seven-year plan will be presented at the Board of Governor's Retreat in January.
Mr. Paul Weber, Chair, Orillia Campus Campaign, reported that Simcoe County had been approached for a pledge for the campaign, noting that a commitment has been received in the sum of $500,000 for the 2009/10 fiscal year. Mr. Weber was confident that this would not be a one-time gift and the fundraising team would continue to work with Simcoe County on similar amounts each year for the next five years. Mr. Weber also noted that the fundraising team is working on a gift of $500,000 to name a portion of the Orillia campus library/learning commons.
Moved by Mr. Crooks, seconded by Mr. Cardwell that the verbal Report be accepted.
Carried unanimously.
9.Report of the Alumni Association
Moved by Ms. Cheng, seconded by Ms. Phipps that the Report of the Alumni Association be accepted.
Carried unanimously.
10.Ratification of Adjunct Professors
Moved by Dr. Gilbert, seconded by Dr. Siddall that the following be ratified as Adjunct Professors:
- Mr. Kevin Cleghorn, Department of Political Science for the term July 1, 2008 to June 30, 2012;
- Dr. Michael Campbell, Department of Chemistry for the term July 1, 2008 to June 30, 2012;
- Dr. Monica Vermani, Department of Psychology for the term July 1, 2008 to June 30, 2012;
- Dr. Diane Walker, School of Social Work for the term July 1, 2008 to June 30, 2012;
- Dr. Laura Curiel, Department of Electrical Engineering for the term July 1, 2008 to June 30, 2012; and
- Dr. Samuel Pichardo, Department of Electrical Engineering for the term July 1, 2008 to June 30, 2012.
Gilbert/Sidall motion was carried.
Items for Information
11.Report of the Lakehead University Student Union
Mr. Longtin spoke to the report of the Lakehead University Student Union which had been circulated at the beginning of the meeting.
12.Report from the Thunder Bay Regional Health Sciences Centre Hospital Board
Mr. Labine reviewed the report of the Thunder Bay Regional Health Sciences Centre Hospital Board which had been circulated with the Agenda.
13. Report of the Northern Ontario School of Medicine
Mr. Cleghorn noted that the NOSM Community Report had been distributed for information.
14.Report of the Board of Governors' Representative to Senate
Mr. Dahl, Board of Governors' Representative to Senate, updated members on the November Senate Meeting, adding that Senate Agendas, Minutes, and backup documentation can be viewed on Senate website. Mr. Dahl highlighted the following items from the November 2008 Senate Meeting:
- students were recognized as 2008/09 major scholarship recipients;
- Mr. Cleghorn addressed Senate; and
- proposed calendar changes were referred to Committee and approved.
15. Re-appointment of Chair of Aboriginal Education in the Faculty of Education
Dr. Gilbert informed Board members that Dr. Ethel Gardner has been appointed for a second term, January 1, 2009 to December 31, 2011, as the Chair of Aboriginal Education.
The meeting, which began at 4:05 p.m., was adjourned at 5:50 p.m., on a motion by Mr. Labine and seconded by Mr. Pile. The meeting moved in camera.
Moved by Mr. Dahl, seconded by Mr. Campbell that the Board of Governors' meeting resume.
The meeting resumed, following the in camera meeting, to discuss the Presidential Search membership. Mr. Cleghorn reported that the five Board members who received the highest votes were Ms. Vonnie Cheng, Mr. Colin Bruce, Ms. Maria Phipps, Mr. Gil Labine, and Mr. Kurt Dahl.
Moved by Mr. Campbell, seconded by Ms. Dumyn that the following Board members be appointed to the Presidential Search Committee: Mr. Colin Bruce, Ms. Vonnie Cheng, Mr. Kurt Dahl, Mr. Gil Labine, and Ms. Maria Phipps.
Carried unanimously.
The meeting, which resumed at 6:10 p.m., was adjourned at 6:15 p.m., on a motion by Mr. Leblanc and seconded by Mr. Labine.
Visits
 
Minister Milloy (Training, Colleges and Universities) and President Genest (Council of Ontario Universities) visited the Thunder Bay Campus during the past month.  We discussed issues of importance to Lakehead University and provided tours of the campus.  Genest met with the Vice Presidents.
 
Research
 
Lakehead University demonstrated substantial growth in research funding over the past 5 years and according to Research Infosource Inc., the 107% increase gave it third place in the undergraduate category and fifth place overall in Canada. The University moved to 30th from 33rd position among the top 50 Canadian research universities.
 
Dr. Aicheng Chen has been awarded the Fred Beamish Award by the Canadian Society for Chemistry.  The Beamish Award recognizes individuals who demonstrate innovation in analytical chemistry research that has significant potential for practical applications.
 
Dr. Peter Hollings, Department of Geology, received the William Harvey Gross Award from The Geological Association of Canada last June and as a consequence, in October was named as “Citizen of Exceptional Achievement” by the City of Thunder Bay.
 
Dr. Rui Wang was senior author of an article published in the prestigious journal Science on the role of hydrogen sulphide in regulatory blood pressure by relaxing blood vessels.
 
Orillia
 
Brian Jeffs has been hired as Assistant Vice-President Administration and Finance stationed in Orillia.  He is working on the Orillia Strategic Plan with Campus Dean Kim Fedderson which will include a revision of the Orillia Campus business plan.
 
Geothermal drilling has been completed on the permanent campus site to assess the potential of this source for heating and cooling of the Phase I building.  Test results were very good.
 
Credit Rating
 
Moody’s analysis of the University’s credit rating left it unchanged at A1.