monster research

On Halloween, Monsters Reign Supreme

Dr. Ryan McVeigh Investigates Our Fascination with the Undead

Interdisciplinary studies professor Dr. Ryan McVeigh is a big fan of Halloween.

"It's the one day a year that we can safely cater to our dark sides by dressing up, putting tombstones on our lawns, and decorating our houses with giant spiderwebs," says Dr. McVeigh, who teaches on Lakehead University's Orillia campus.

"It's essentially a cultural excuse to shape shift and become something that we normally are not."

A head-and-shoulders photo of Dr. Ryan McVeigh with a wooden fence and trees visible behind him"Doppelgangers are my favourite monster," says Dr. McVeigh. "They're perfectly captured in an 1846 short story by Fyodor Dostoevsky called 'The Double.' Doppelgangers are like an evil twin who can get you into trouble for something you didn't do. They can upend your life and that's terrifying. Imagine if someone had your face print and fingerprints, which is a legitimate fear in today's technological, biometric society."

And he is not alone. Dr. McVeigh points out that the spooky season is growing ever more popular. According to a poll conducted by Statutory Holidays Canada, only Canada Day and Christmas rank higher as our favourite day of the year.

"But," he adds, "it's interesting to ask, 'Why does dressing up as a witch or a murderous clown or a vampire appeal to us?'"

This question has been preoccupying Dr. McVeigh for several years—and he's been on the hunt for answers.

He teaches a third-year interdisciplinary course called "Monsters" that approaches this topic from a sociological and philosophical perspective.

"I'm using the course as a way to field test my monster research," he explains.

"Other scholars have argued that monsters disrupt what humans believe they know about the world by upsetting taken-for-granted cultural categories. Undead creatures, for instance, are monsters that violate our understanding of life and death. This disruption is part of why they horrify, and what justifies human violence towards them."

A small child stands in a living room wearing a devil mask and a striped costume with white glovesOn Halloween, I wear a costume when I take my kids trick or treating," Dr. McVeigh says. "Last year, I dressed up as Elliott from the movie E.T. I found the front of a bicycle, attached a basket to it, and put a toy alien in the basket." Above, a childhood photo of Dr. McVeigh getting into the Halloween spirit.

Calling someone a monster has been used—historically and in the present—to justify violence against people classified as "other." The witch trials in Europe and North America, which were at their height during the religious upheaval of the 1500s and 1600s, remain one of the most notorious examples of what can happen when we demonize our fellow human beings.

"It was mostly hysteria and a cover to destroy political beliefs that diverged from Christianity," Dr. McVeigh says. "It was likewise an excellent excuse to target a neighbour who had more land than you or a customer who didn't pay their bill."

Through his research, he has found that monsters speak to our deeper fears and anxieties about differences and a loss of status. Zombies, for instance, threaten our sense of self by reducing individuals to members of a mindless horde.

A man with outstretched arms dressed as a zombie walks through an area with trees; two other people dressed as zombies walk behind him
"Being afraid of zombies and not ghosts could mean that someone is afraid of disease, contamination, and decay, because zombies are a type of body horror," Dr. McVeigh explains. Zombies are now a popular trope in movies and TV shows like "The Walking Dead." "For years, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention published an emergency preparedness plan, but almost no one paid attention to it. In 2011, they published the "Preparedness 101: Zombie Apocalypse" graphic novel and had a much better response. Photo Credit: Pexels/Cottonbro

His research is also building upon findings that certain monsters persist across the world and across cultures.

So far, Dr. McVeigh has identified eight monster archetypes, and he's currently investigating whether other such archetypes exist.

The archetypes that he has documented are vampires, zombies, shapeshifters (such as werewolves), ghosts, doppelgangers, witches, devils/demons, and aliens.

Outsiders Can Evoke Fear and Terror

Previously, Dr. McVeigh's research focused on the field of human cognition, in particular how cognitive behaviour and cognitive processes relate to group dynamics. Central to this research is the study of the sense of belonging, which allows an individual to be a member of a group.

"One day, I asked myself, 'Who isn't ever allowed to belong?'" Dr. McVeigh says. "When I realized that the answer was 'monsters,' I decided to study them."

He is intrigued by humans' contradictory relationships with monsters. Although we define ourselves by not being monsters, we sometimes root for them.

"We are simultaneously fascinated and horrified by monsters because we are secretly attracted to them," Dr. McVeigh says.

"As a 12-year-old-boy, I loved watching Godzilla and alien monsters destroy cities, but I was equally delighted by the monsters' downfalls."

That's because despite their monstrosity, these creatures can have characteristics that we crave. "Think about vampires who live forever and have super strength or werewolves that literally shed their skin and give into their primal urges."

Two children dressed as ghosts stand behind a cobwebbed window; one child holds a jack-o'-lantern and one child holds a large knife and a cell phone
In some cases, ghosts can be comforting and in other cases they can be terrifying. "Many students are very willing to talk about how they felt the presence of their grandmother at their graduation or how they saw a glowing light at the same time that their grandfather died, which gave them hope," Dr. McVeigh says. "But if people believe that a place is haunted by malevolent ghosts or poltergeists, they react with fear." Photo Credit: Pexels/Karola G

He says it's not uncommon for people who feel marginalized or powerless to be fans of monsters. They are drawn to the fantasy of being able to destroy the group that oppresses them. "In the 2025 movie adaptation of 'Frankenstein,' Dr. Victor Frankenstein was obviously the real monster; many audience members were happy when the creature killed his creator."

Dr. McVeigh believes that reading monster stories and watching monster movies and TV shows are a safe and socially acceptable outlet for humans' violent impulses.

But a fascination with monsters can tip over into something dangerous. He notes that a rise in social and political discourse centred around monsters can be a sign of fractured social relationships.

One way this is manifesting in the present moment is in the actions of governments depicting immigrants as "monsters," rather than as human beings, and who are using this as a pretext to strip people of their civil rights. "Monsters say something about human cruelty and how close it is to the surface," Dr. McVeigh says.

Unpacking these behaviours and motivations drives the work of Dr. McVeigh and his students as they try to better understand human nature.

"Zombies, vampires, and Godzilla get students in the door of my classroom, but they stay because it gives them the opportunity to talk about the idea of belonging and what we're afraid of."

Subscribe to monster research